
What De Beers’ Mine Closure Says About the Value of Scarcity
South Africa's biggest diamond mine is going quiet for two years. The diamonds haven't run out. What ran out is the price people will pay for something being hard to find.
Venetia sits in Limpopo, in the far north of South Africa, close to the borders with Botswana and Zimbabwe. It is De Beers' last working mine in the country. It produces more than 40% of South Africa's diamonds and employs about 4,400 people. In July, De Beers said it would stop mining there for two years.
Mines usually close because the ground gives out. Venetia's hasn't. Its output was up 53% in the first quarter of this year. It is stopping because fewer people want to pay what its diamonds used to cost.
The diamonds are exactly as rare as they were last year. Rarity is just worth less.
The stone and the story, separated
In 2019, about 12% of engagement rings bought in the US had a lab-grown centre stone. According to The Knot's latest jewellery study, last year it was 61%. The average lab-grown engagement ring cost $4,300. The average mined one cost $7,000.
A lab-grown diamond is the same carbon, arranged the same way, with the same hardness and the same fire. A jeweller needs a machine to tell them apart. Meanwhile, the price of mined diamonds has fallen to its lowest level in about two decades.
So people haven't stopped wanting diamonds. They've stopped paying extra for the part of the diamond they can't see. Given the choice between the stone and its origin, most buyers have quietly decided they only wanted one of them.
That is a bigger statement than it sounds. For a century, the diamond trade has sold its product as something formed over billions of years and found against the odds. It turns out that, at a $2,700 premium, most couples would rather have the same thing made last month.
Nobody gets a clean win
It would be easy to call this progress and leave it there. It's more tangled than that.
A lab-grown diamond has almost no resale value. The price of new lab stones keeps falling, so the one you bought is worth less each year. Growing one takes a huge amount of electricity, and how clean that is depends entirely on the grid powering the reactor.
A mined diamond carries its own costs. Digging it out leaves a mark on the land, and the trade has a long history of human harm in some places. But it also pays wages. At Venetia, that means about 4,400 people whose work is now on hold.
The mined market isn't disappearing either. It's narrowing. Buyers who still want a mined stone are moving towards vintage stones, warmer colours and natural coloured diamonds. Those are stones whose appeal is something you can point to, not just their scarcity.
Diamonds are just going first
None of this is new. It's just never happened this fast, or to something this famous.
Mikimoto started culturing pearls in Japan in the 1890s. Today almost every pearl sold is farmed, and natural pearls have become a niche for collectors. Rubies have been made in labs since 1902, when the French chemist Auguste Verneuil perfected a way to grow them. Lab-made rubies are cheap and everywhere. A natural Burmese ruby can still sell for millions at auction. In 2023, lab-grown chicken was approved for sale in the US.
The pattern repeats. The lab version doesn't kill the natural one. It pushes it upwards into something rarer, and it hollows out the middle.
That middle is where most diamonds used to sell: the mid-priced mined stone, bought because it was the only option, by people who never thought much about where it came from. Those buyers are gone.
When science can make the same thing for so much less, every industry built on rarity has to work out what it's really selling. The uncomfortable question for those industries is whether their customers were ever paying for rarity, or just for the fact that nothing else was available.
Trending Post
Stay up-to-date





