
Why the Language of Less Sells More
Hailey Bieber says she's not interested in overconsumption. But when a celebrity brand's real product is attention, overconsumption isn't a side effect of the model. It's the model.
As beauty brands increasingly frame themselves around essentials and longevity, Hailey Bieber's comments on overconsumption raise a sharper question for the industry: can a business built on growth genuinely encourage people to buy less?
Few beauty brands of the past decade have grown as quickly as Rhode. Hailey Bieber launched the skincare label in 2022 with just three products, each priced under $30, pitched as a pared-back alternative to the crowded, multi-step routines that had come to define the category (Forbes). Four years later, Rhode is one of the most closely watched names in beauty. In 2025, it was acquired by e.l.f. Beauty in a deal valued at up to $1 billion, and it is reportedly on track for around $300 million in North American sales this year, with people close to Sephora describing it as the retailer's top-performing brand (Puck).
It was against that backdrop that Bieber took the stage at Fortune's Most Powerful Women Summit in Santa Barbara this week. Speaking about the brand's philosophy, she told the audience she is "not interested in overconsumption," adding that the beauty market is already very crowded. Rhode, she said, was shaped by the essentials she relied on while working and travelling on her own from the age of 17.
The remarks quickly drew scrutiny online, where critics questioned how a brand known for frequent launches, accessories and elaborate influencer gifting squares with a stance against overconsumption. The debate says less about one founder than about a wider tension in beauty, where the language of restraint has become an increasingly effective way to sell.
"I am not interested in overconsumption." Hailey Bieber, Fortune Most Powerful Women Summit
A strategy built on seeding
Much of the criticism centred on influencer gifting, a practice that has become central to how beauty brands launch products. Like many of its peers, Rhode seeds new releases through boxes sent to creators, designed to be unboxed on camera and shared at scale. The approach is effective precisely because it concentrates attention: a single launch can generate millions of views, and with them a wave of demand for the same product at the same moment.
The environmental cost of that model has long been a point of contention within the industry. In one widely shared example, the product occupied less than 5% of the box it was sent in, and a survey of more than 350 beauty insiders found that 81% considered PR packaging excessive (Dazed). Researchers at Washington State University, who analysed 131 public PR unboxing videos, found that packaging waste went largely unmentioned, even when brands presented themselves as sustainable (WSU).
Packaging is a more nuanced story. Some of Rhode's packaging, including that of its best-known Peptide Lip Treatment, is made with post-consumer recycled materials (MECCA). However, the brand does not currently appear to offer refills, meaning each finished product is replaced in full. In an industry where some estimates suggest as much as 95% of cosmetic packaging ends up in landfill, refillable formats would arguably do more to address both waste and overconsumption than any statement of intent.
Intentions and incentives
Ownership adds a further layer. As part of e.l.f. Beauty, a publicly listed company, Rhode now operates within a structure that measures success through quarterly growth. That growth is typically delivered through new launches, new categories and new reasons to buy, a dynamic that sits uneasily with a message of restraint, however sincerely it is held.
Rhode is far from alone in this. Across the industry, "skin longevity" is replacing "anti-ageing" as a defining theme, while "skinimalism", the idea of using fewer products that do more, is increasingly described as a mindset rather than a passing trend (Beauty Independent, Net-a-Porter). On the surface, this suggests a sector moving towards less. In practice, a pared-back aesthetic, neutral packaging and the language of essentials can signal restraint while the launch calendar continues to expand.
The more uncomfortable reading is that Bieber's comments are likely sincere, and that sincerity alone changes little. When a celebrity brand's most valuable asset is attention, overconsumption is less a side effect of the model than a feature of it.
"The language of less has become one of the best ways to sell more."
That need not be the end of the story. A beauty brand genuinely committed to reducing overconsumption would make that commitment visible in its operations rather than its messaging: refills for core products, lighter and plastic-free influencer seeding sent only to those who want it, fewer and more deliberate launches, and products designed to be used up and repurchased rather than collected. None of this would require abandoning growth, only measuring it differently.
For now, the test of a brand against overconsumption is not what its founder says on stage, but whether it would ever choose to sell less.
Trending Post
Stay up-to-date




